Running a successful Shopify store in the pet supplies and pet food vertical means more than just having great products and cute branding. Pet owners are incredibly loyal to the brands they trust, but they also expect shopping experiences that are helpful, relevant, and efficient. That’s where eCommerce personalization comes in.
By tailoring product recommendations, search results, and email content to the unique needs of each customer and their pets, Shopify pet brands can increase average order value (AOV), improve conversion rates, and keep customers coming back for more.
Here’s how pet-focused Shopify stores can use personalization across merchandising, site search, and email to grow their business.
Page Contents
1. Smarter Merchandising for Bigger Baskets
Every pet is different — and so is every pet owner. A shopper with a large-breed senior dog has different needs than someone with a new kitten. Personalized merchandising helps you deliver relevant product suggestions based on each customer’s past behavior and preferences.
How to personalize merchandising in a pet store:
- Dynamic product recommendations: Show recommended products based on the customer’s pet type, breed, and purchase history. If someone frequently buys grain-free dog food, highlight compatible treats or supplements.
- Tailored category pages: Sort and prioritize product listings based on what the customer is most likely to buy. For example, a shopper who always buys cat litter could see top-rated cat toys or scratching posts first when browsing.
- Bundled offers: Suggest personalized product bundles, like “Senior Dog Wellness Pack” or “New Puppy Starter Kit,” which include food, toys, and grooming essentials. These kits can boost AOV while helping customers feel confident they’re getting everything their pet needs.
Using Shopify plugins like Nosto, Wiser, or LimeSpot, you can create real-time recommendations and merchandising blocks that adjust dynamically for each visitor. The result? More relevant products in front of the right customers, leading to higher sales per session.
2. Personalized Site Search That Understands Pet Parents
When pet owners search your store, they often know what they’re looking for. But traditional search can fall short by serving generic results that don’t reflect personal preferences or pet-specific needs.
How to optimize site search for personalization:
- Search re-ranking: Adjust product rankings in search results based on previous interactions. If a customer regularly buys organic cat food, those items should appear at the top of their search for “cat food.”
- Intelligent autocomplete: Help users find products faster by offering personalized suggestions as they type. A shopper who previously browsed “hypoallergenic dog food” could be nudged toward top-selling options in that category.
- Error-proof search: When a customer types something imprecise like “dog vitamins,” smart search can guide them to relevant categories or best sellers instead of producing a “no results” page.
Solutions like Searchspring and Boost AI Search integrate with Shopify and make it easy to personalize the on-site search experience, helping customers find what they need faster and more reliably. And that means more conversions from high-intent shoppers.
3. Behavioral Email Campaigns That Bring Customers Back
Email remains one of the most effective tools for building customer relationships — especially in a vertical like pet supplies, where customers need to reorder food, litter, and grooming products regularly. Personalization helps you time your messages and content perfectly for each customer.
Ways to personalize email marketing for pet supply stores:
- Replenishment reminders: Use purchase history to estimate when a customer is likely running low on food, treats, or litter. Send a friendly reminder email with one-click reordering and personalized suggestions based on their past purchases.
- Post-purchase upsells: After someone buys dog food, follow up with recommendations for digestive supplements, feeding bowls, or training treats that match their preferences.
- Segmented campaigns: Tailor promotions and product launches based on pet type, breed size, or dietary needs. For instance, promote a new line of freeze-dried cat food only to customers who previously purchased premium cat products.
- Birthday or gotcha day emails: Collect pet birthdays or adoption dates during sign-up and send celebratory emails with special discounts or gift ideas.
Platforms like Klaviyo, Drip, and Omnisend work seamlessly with Shopify and let you create automated, data-driven flows that increase repeat purchases and customer loyalty.
The Revenue Impact of Personalization
In a vertical like pet supplies, where customers buy regularly and tend to stick with trusted brands, personalization can significantly increase lifetime value. With smarter merchandising, more relevant search results, and perfectly timed emails, you can:
- Raise average order value by cross-selling and bundling relevant products
- Improve conversion rates by helping shoppers find the right items faster
- Boost retention by creating experiences tailored to each pet and owner
- Reduce churn with timely reminders and relevant re-engagement campaigns
Final Thoughts
Pet parents don’t just shop for products — they shop for their beloved companions. By personalizing your Shopify store experience, you show customers that you understand and support their specific needs.
Whether you’re selling grain-free dog treats, eco-friendly litter, or custom pet collars, personalization helps you deliver the right message to the right customer at the right time. And when you do that consistently, you build trust, grow average order size, and turn one-time buyers into lifelong fans.
For Shopify pet supply brands, personalization isn’t just a nice-to-have. It’s a growth engine. Start small, optimize often, and let data guide you toward smarter, more loyal customer relationships.
Also Read:
Lois Lane is a professional blogger and a seasoned Content writer for wellhousekeeping.com. With a passion for simplifying complex Home Decor topics, he provides valuable insights to a diverse online audience. With four years of experience, Lois has polished his skills as a professional blogger.
